Monday, 28 November 2011

What is REDD+?

    
The annual United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) climate talks have started today in Durban, South Africa. The 17th Conference of the Parties (COP17) will last two weeks with the aim to facilitate a global agreement to tackle anthropogenic climate change. Forests are one of the main agenda items for the COP in the form of  Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD). This post aims to provide a short introduction to REDD, the world of forests and deforestation from an international policy perspective.

According to the definition of the UN-REDD Program, REDD is “an effort to create a financial value for the carbon stored in forests, offering incentives for developing countries to reduce emissions from forested lands and invest in low-carbon paths to sustainable development”.  REDD gradually evolved to REDD+ where the plus indicates “the role of conservation, sustainable management of forests and enhancement of forest carbon stocks”. REDD was first introduced to the agenda of the UNFCCC in December 2005 at its eleventh session. As a result of the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, the UNFCCC entered into force in 1994, signed by 194 countries, with the ultimate goal of “stabilizing greenhouse gas concentrations at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic (human induced) interference with the climate system.

The Little REDD Book, published by the Global Canopy Programme in 2008, is one of the best introductory readings if someone wants to dig a little more into the world of REDD(+). REDD(+) is a complex mechanisms for which a number of issues are still actively debated. Drawn from the Little REDD Book I will briefly discuss some of the most important aspects and challenges of REDD(+), which also shows the complexity of the subject.

Scope: Concerns the activities included (REDD or REDD+), participating countries, and different carbon pools such as above ground biomass, below ground biomass, soil carbon and/or all terrestrial carbon.

Reference levels: Relates to the measurement of emission reductions from REDD(+). If REDD(+) used for meeting binding or voluntary emission reduction commitments of countries there must be a system to measure exact emission reductions. Thus reference levels basically define “the period and scale against which the activities within scope are measured”. Options currently discuss include sub-national, national or global (in terms of scale) and historic baseline, current or projected baseline (in terms of reference period).

Distribution: relates to “how the benefits of those reductions will be allocated”.  While the majority of UNFCCC countries promote “compensation directly in line with a [country]’s own actions” others suggest that “some of these benefits should be redistributed to [countries] other than those generating the emissions reductions” (e.g. “allocate funds to historically low emitters who may emit at some point into the future” as a preventive measure).

Financing: addresses the “where the money comes from” question. Possible alternatives include financing through a voluntary fund, Official Development Assistance (ODA) – although most developing countries call for “new and additional funds”, a direct-market based mechanism (where emission reductions are traded on the market, or a market-linked mechanism. (A basic understanding of emissions trading and markets may help grasping this topic better.)
  
While the exact details of a REDD(+) mechanism are still debated, countries of the UNFCCC agree that a mechanisms must be set up to reduce emissions from forests, a sector that amounts to almost 20% of global warming emissions and thus can clearly not be ignored. Finding a system, however, that is suitable and acceptable to all the 194 member countries of the UNFCCC is challenging. There are, nonetheless, initiatives already in place (such as the UN-REDD Programme or the Forest Carbon Partnership Facility) with the aim to pilot REDD+ projects and prepare developing rainforest countries (with appropriate policies and technologies) for the implementation of a future REDD+ mechanism.
   

Saturday, 26 November 2011

Community forestry in the Amazon

  
Community forestry usually refers to a forest management system where local communities and/or indigenous people are involved in forestry activities with the aim to develop sustainable forest use. Community forest management can be a great tool in achieving the combined benefits of forest conservation, rural development and poverty reduction. There are numerous community forest management programs all around the world, however, success rates depend on a number of factors, and most importantly, it seems, on tenure sequrity. 

The Overseas Development Institute (ODI), in 2008, published the report ‘Community Forestry in the Amazon: the unsolved challenge of forests and the poor’ with the aim to assess efforts put into the establishment of community forest programs in the Amazon region and the reasons for their high rate of failure.

One of the issues mentioned is the ignorance of traditional focus on rural procedures on agricultural production and the extraction of Non Timber Forest Products (NTFPs). Ignoring the cultural preference of horizontal organizational structures and activities with immediate economic returns, implementing organizations tend to push vertical organizational structures and focus on long-term economic gains. As a result, these programs often fail due to lack of support from local communities. Another problematic area discussed in the report is the communication gap that can occur between professional foresters and local communities. Moreover, most community forestry programs require significant subsidies to cover operational costs for a substantial period of time and revoking financial support can lead to almost immediate collapse.  

Nonetheless, according to the ODA it is not the principle of forest management by communities that is in question but the current framework. To achieve success, the report argues, “a clearer vision of the aspirations of indigenous communities in the region is needed”, which “will help to define more coherent and realistic policies which promote the effective use of forests by smallholders as an important input for the sustainable development of the region and as a means of reducing rural poverty”.
    

100 years old farmer in the Juma Reserve in the Brazilian Amazon
Photo: Neil Palmer (CIAT)
Source: CIFOR Forests Blog

     

Thursday, 24 November 2011

Uncontacted Amazon Tribe: First ever aerial footage

  
A previously unknown indigenous group was discovered deep in the Amazon rainforest, in one of the dense jungles of the Javari Valley Indigenous Reserve in western Brazil. The aerial footage, below, was released by officials of Brazil’s Indian Affairs Agency (FUNAI), who initially discovered the tribe during examination of satellite images of rain forest clearings. They estimate that the tribe might number as many as 200 people.  
   
The Javari Reserve is home to the largest concentration of uncontacted tribes in the entire world, with at least eight uncontacted indigenous communities, and perhaps as many as fourteen, inhabiting the upland forests.


Tuesday, 22 November 2011

Rainforests on Fire

   
In his 2003 article,
Fire Science for Rainforests, Mark A. Cochrane explains that while tropical forest fires have never been unprecedented, the problem is the frequency with which they are nowadays being burned. Fires in tropical forests have return intervals of hundreds or even thousands of years. As a result, tropical rainforest are evolutionarily not adapted to current patterns of fires, with thin barks that provide little protection even against low intensity fires.

Most fires in tropical rainforests are associated with forest edges and are mostly arise from ‘slash and burn’ practices getting out of control. Forest edges, borders of forested and deforested land, generally have increased mortality of trees, decreased living biomass and increased fuel loads (dry wood debris), which makes these forests susceptible to fire. While due to their high sub-canopy humidity extensive undamaged forests make large forest fires almost impossible, current levels of fragmentation in tropical forests (with scattered deforested areas) make large areas of forestland threatened. In addition, extensive selective logging (when only certain trees are removed but in large numbers) significantly decreases forest biomass and can thus also increase fire susceptibility.

Cochrane points out that frequent tropical forest fires lead to a vicious cycle where forests thinned by fire transpire less water, which leads to lower humidity and as a result increased future fire probability. Instead of applying fire knowledge from other parts of the world, Cochrane says, to prevent the continuous loss of large areas of tropical forests “current fire knowledge needs to be interpreted in the context of tropical forests and, where necessary, added to, by defining the mechanisms by which fire and ecosystem processes interact in these forests."


Photo: Daniel Beltra,
www.danielbeltra.com
 

Friday, 18 November 2011

Carbon sequestration by forests


Following on from my earlier post on deforestation and climate change, I will now discuss the role of trees and forests in mitigating anthropogenic climate change in more detail.

The potential key role of forests in mitigation of anthropogenic climate change is widely acknowledged both by scientists and policy makers. International policies to ensure the protection and sustanable management of forests are emerging rapidly, with increasing focus on reforestation and afforestation activities. However, carbon sequestration by forests is a complex mechanism, effected by numerous factors, which makes the accurate calculation of potential and actual carbon sequestration challenging. This issue is especially relevant for policies and mechanisms that allow countries to untilize forest carbon sequestration to meet their emission reduction targets as failure to properly calculate carbon sequestration can lead to inappropriate global emission reductions.

Forests play a crucial role in the global carbon cycle. Through photosynthesis they assimilate carbon dioxide (CO2) and fix carbon (C) in their biomass releasing oxygen (O2) as a waste product. Forest ecosystems store an estimated 638 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon, 283 Gt of which in forest biomass alone, which is approximately 50% more than all the carbon in the atmosphere. This makes forests the single largest terrestrial carbon sinks (1). As a result, minor changes in forest ecosystems can have great impacts on the carbon cycle and therefore on the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere (2). According to some estimates, the terrestrial biosphere currently sequesters around 3 billion tons of anthropogenic carbon annually, 20-30% of global anthropogenic CO2 emissions (3). Forests, however, can switch between being a net sink of carbon to being a net source, depending on succession stage, disturbance or management regime.

While the role of undisturbed forests as climate protectors is not questioned, it is hard to determine both the forest carbon sink and reservoir that can be managed and the exact amount of carbon forests at any point may remove from the atmosphere (4). As Canadell & Raupach (2008) describes, the upper limit of carbon sequestration can be estimated by the carbon emitted from historical land conversion. If 75% of this came from forest conversion, they suggest, and therefore can be returned by reforestation over the course of the 21st century, a mitigation potential of about 1.5 Pg carbon annually can be calculated. This would reduce atmospheric CO2 concentration by 40 to 70 parts per million (ppm) by 2100. While these numbers are very imprecise, the method is still useful for providing estimates of global forest sequestration potential.

At a more localized scale, however, there can be great variability in sequestration potential of different forest types as well as between natural and production or plantation forests. This makes the calculation of sequestration potential challenging, as models and methods should be adjusted to specific forests and environments (5). For example, Vyskot et al. (2011) notes that, depending on various factors such as site conditions or species composition, the average biomass of production forests only reaches about 20-60% of biomass in natural forests. 

Finally, carbon sequestration by forests can be affected by a number of physical, chemical and biological factors, such as climate warming, the concentration of CO2 or ozone in the atmosphere, respiration rates, nitrogen deposition, biological invasions, or management regime. This means that in order to provide accurate estimates of sequestration potential of forests over time, not only their present state but potential future environmental changes should also be considered. 
   

Thursday, 17 November 2011

The Prince's Rainforests Project

  
The PRP’s work - that was largely concluded in Oslo in May 2010 when over fifty Governments launched the REDD+ Partnership - focused on two very specific aims. The first, to identify appropriate incentives to encourage rainforest nations to slow their deforestation rates. The second, to raise awareness of the link between rainforests and climate change.

The PRP is now part of The Prince’s Charities’ International Sustainability Unit, a programme of work to help build consensus on how to develop durable solutions which will underpin the mechanisms required to meet the challenges of climate change and natural resource depletion.

As part of the project an interactive rainforest booklet was published to raise awareness of the importance of rainforest protection. Click here to access the online booklet.

Featured pages of the PRP's interactive online booklet